Buffalo Games Squishmallows Buddies Jigsaw Puzzle - 100-Piec
✅ PROS
- Thick, durable puzzle board pieces that hold up to repeated assembly
- Adorable Squishmallows artwork that appeals to both kids and adult collectors
- Full-size 8x8 inch finished puzzle — larger than typical 100-piece sets
❌ CONS
- Some pieces arrive with minor peeling at the edges due to manufacturing
- Not challenging enough for experienced puzzlers — strictly for casual/family use
The Verdict
Let’s be honest: most 100-piece puzzles are an afterthought purchase. You grab one for a rainy day, the kid finishes it in 20 minutes, and it lives in a drawer forever. The Buffalo Games Squishmallows Buddies puzzle is different — not because it’s harder, but because it’s better made and genuinely enjoyable to complete. Here’s the breakdown.
What You Actually Get
The box contains 100 jigsaw pieces that assemble into a finished puzzle measuring 8x8 inches. That’s a full foot of colorful Squishmallows characters — Cam the Cat, Fifi the Fox, and friends — rendered in the brand’s signature soft, chunky art style. The pieces are cut from recycled puzzle board, a nice touch for eco-conscious buyers, and they have a matte finish that reduces glare under bright lights. The box itself is compact and sturdy, easy to store or toss in a bag for travel.
Build Quality & Real-World Performance
The standout feature here is the piece thickness. Buffalo Games uses a denser board than most budget puzzle brands, and it shows. Pieces snap together with a satisfying click and hold firm — you can lift the completed puzzle by the edges without it falling apart. That’s a big deal if you’ve ever wrestled with flimsy pieces that bend or separate mid-assembly.
The print quality is sharp, with vibrant colors that pop. The Squishmallows characters are distinct enough that even younger kids can identify where pieces go without constant adult intervention. The cut pattern is varied — no two pieces are identical shapes — which adds a slight challenge without becoming frustrating.
What Buyers Consistently Praise
Across 235 ratings (4.7 stars), the recurring theme is surprise at the quality. One reviewer wrote: “I bought this for my 6-year-old who’s Squishmallows-obsessed. She finished it in one sitting and immediately wanted to do it again. The pieces are thicker than our other puzzles.” Another noted: “The colors are so much brighter in person than on the screen. My daughter framed it and hung it in her room.”
Parents also appreciate that it’s a screen-free activity that actually holds attention. Several reviewers mentioned using it as a quiet-time activity or a birthday gift that didn’t require batteries.
Where It Falls Short
No product is perfect, and this one has two honest flaws. First, a few pieces arrive with minor edge peeling — the top layer can separate slightly from the cardboard core. It’s cosmetic and doesn’t affect assembly, but if you’re a stickler for pristine packaging, it might annoy you. Second, it’s not a challenge for experienced puzzlers. This is squarely a family/casual product. If you’re looking for a brain-bender, look elsewhere.
Who Should Buy This
- Squishmallows collectors (yes, adults count — this makes a cute desk display)
- Parents of kids ages 5-9 who want a quality first puzzle experience
- Teachers or caregivers looking for a quiet, portable activity
- Gift-givers who need a reliable, universally-appealing present under $15
Skip it if you’re a hardcore puzzler or if your kid is under 4 (small pieces are a choking hazard).
FAQ: 3 Real Questions Shoppers Ask
Q: Is this puzzle suitable for a 4-year-old? A: It’s borderline. The pieces are larger than standard 100-piece puzzles, but still small enough to be a choking hazard. If your 4-year-old doesn’t mouth objects, it’s fine with supervision. Otherwise, wait a year.
Q: Does the box come with a reference image? A: Yes, the box lid shows the full artwork. Some buyers also photograph the lid with their phone to reference while assembling — a handy trick.
Q: Can the finished puzzle be glued and framed? A: Absolutely. The matte finish takes puzzle glue well. Several reviewers have framed theirs as wall art.
The Verdict
Buy it if you want a well-made, adorable puzzle that delivers exactly what it promises — a fun, quality family activity that looks great when finished.
Skip it if you need a challenging puzzle or have very young children.
Rating: 4.6/5 — the minor peeling issue keeps it from a perfect score, but for the price and purpose, this is one of the better 100-piece puzzles you can buy. Buffalo Games clearly put thought into the materials, and it shows.
Where to Buy
We earn a small commission at no extra cost to you — this helps fund more honest reviews.
Last updated: 2026-08-06. Ratings and prices current as of review date. Verify on Amazon before purchasing.