ColourPop Lippie Lip Pencil Vault - High-Pigment, Long-Lasti
✅ PROS
- 24 full-size lip liners for $29 — roughly $1.20 per pencil, far cheaper than buying individually
- Creamy, non-drying formula that glides on without tugging and layers well under gloss or lipstick
- Shade range spans nudes, pinks, reds, berries, and deeper tones — genuinely versatile for most skin tones
❌ CONS
- No sharpener included in the vault; you'll need to buy one separately since these are sharpenable pencils
- A few of the lighter nude shades can look chalky on deeper skin tones — test before committing to a full look
- The cardboard packaging is functional but not travel-friendly; pencils can roll around loose once opened
The Verdict
Is the ColourPop Lippie Lip Pencil Vault the best bang-for-your-buck lip product on Amazon right now? At $29 for 24 full-size pencils, the math is compelling. But quantity doesn’t always equal quality. Here’s the honest breakdown after working through this set.
What You Actually Get
The vault contains 24 full-size Lippie Pencils — the same 0.04 oz formula ColourPop sells individually for $7-8 each. The shades span the spectrum: warm nudes like BFF and Contour, pinks like Sike and Screenshot, bold reds including Trust Me and Creeper, and deeper berries like Bull Chic and Love Bug. As shown in the product image, the pencils are arranged in a rainbow gradient, which makes shade hunting easy.
Each pencil is sharpenable (not twist-up), so you’ll need a sharpener — the vault doesn’t include one. That’s a small oversight worth flagging.
Performance and Wear
The formula is where ColourPop has always excelled, and this set doesn’t disappoint. The texture is creamy but not slippery — it glides on smoothly without tugging at delicate lip skin. You can wear these alone for a matte, blotted look or use them as a base underneath lipstick to extend wear time. I tested Creeper under a gloss for six hours through coffee, lunch, and a long meeting. The liner held its color while the gloss faded — exactly what you want from a liner.
Pigmentation is genuinely high. Most shades deliver full opacity in one pass, which matters for darker colors where patchiness is common. The lighter nudes (Contour, BFF) need two passes for even coverage on medium-to-deep skin, but that’s consistent with most liner formulas in this price range.
What Buyers Are Saying
Across 225 Amazon ratings at 4.5 stars, the pattern is consistent. One verified buyer noted: “I bought these for the shade range alone — 24 colors for the price of three singles. The formula is creamy and doesn’t dry out my lips like other liners I’ve tried.” Another wrote: “Great pigmentation, but bring your own sharpener. I didn’t realize they weren’t twist-ups.”
The most common criticisms center on packaging and shade selection. A few reviewers mentioned that the cardboard sleeve doesn’t protect the pencils well during travel, and some lighter shades didn’t work for deeper complexions.
Where It Falls Short
Let’s be direct about the tradeoffs. First, no sharpener included — that’s an extra $5-8 purchase. Second, the shade range leans toward lighter and medium tones. If you have deep skin, you’ll find maybe 6-8 shades that work as liners; the rest are better for lip art or mixing. Third, the packaging is functional but not premium. This is a value set, not a luxury presentation.
One more thing: these are not transfer-proof. They’re long-wearing, but they’ll leave a trace on coffee cups and mask edges. That’s expected for a pencil formula, but worth knowing if you’re expecting budge-proof wear.
Who Should Buy This
This vault is ideal for three types of shoppers:
- Beginners building out a lip collection without spending $100+ on individual liners
- Makeup artists or content creators who need a broad shade range for different clients and looks
- Experimenters who want to try bold colors without committing to full-price singles
Skip it if you exclusively use twist-up liners (the sharpening requirement will annoy you) or if you only reach for one or two signature shades — singles are cheaper in that case.
FAQ
Are these lip liners cruelty-free? Yes. ColourPop is a cruelty-free brand and does not test on animals. They’re also vegan-friendly for most shades.
How long does each pencil last with regular use? With daily use and regular sharpening, expect 4-6 weeks per pencil. The full vault realistically lasts 1-2 years.
Can these be used as full lip color? Absolutely. The formula is pigmented enough to wear alone as a matte lip. Add a balm or gloss on top for comfort if you have dry lips.
The Verdict
Buy it if: You want maximum shade variety at a price that won’t hurt, and you don’t mind sharpening pencils.
Skip it if: You prefer twist-up mechanisms, have deep skin tones needing more inclusive shades, or want premium packaging.
Rating: 4.6/5 — The value proposition is undeniable. For $29, you’re getting a versatile, high-performing liner collection that covers most everyday needs. The sharpener omission and shade range limitations keep it from a perfect score, but for most shoppers, this is a smart, budget-friendly win.
Where to Buy
We earn a small commission at no extra cost to you — this helps fund more honest reviews.
Last updated: 2026-08-06. Ratings and prices current as of review date. Verify on Amazon before purchasing.