BLACK+DECKER 4-Slice Toaster Oven, TO1745SSG, Even Toast, 4 inch
✅ PROS
- Even Toast technology delivers consistent browning across all 4 slices, not just the middle two
- Compact footprint (about 16 inches wide) fits under standard cabinets without sacrificing 4-slice capacity
- Dual-function controls with separate toast shade dial and temperature knob for precise cooking across all 4 modes
❌ CONS
- No interior light — you'll need to peek through the glass door to monitor browning progress
- Crumb tray is thin gauge metal and can warp slightly if cleaned while still hot
The Verdict
The $50 toaster oven that actually toasts evenly — and does a few other tricks too
Most budget toaster ovens share a dirty secret: they promise “4-slice capacity” but burn the two slices closest to the heating elements while leaving the middle pair pale and doughy. The BLACK+DECKER TO1745SSG takes a different approach with its Even Toast system, and after looking at what 225 buyers have to say, this compact unit might be the best value under $60 in the category.
What you actually get
The TO1745SSG ships with the toaster oven itself, a wire rack, a bake pan, and a removable crumb tray. No surprises, no useless accessories. The stainless steel body resists fingerprints better than most budget units, and the front glass door gives you a clear view of your food. Physical dials control the timer, temperature (up to 450°F), and toast shade — there’s no digital display, which keeps things simple and repairable.
How it performs in real use
The headline feature is the Even Toast system, which uses a specially designed heating element layout to distribute heat more uniformly across the entire cooking surface. Multiple buyers confirmed this works as advertised. One reviewer noted, “I’ve had toaster ovens that cost twice as much that couldn’t produce consistent toast — this one nails it every time.” Another mentioned they’ve “used it daily for 8 months and toast comes out the same shade every single time.”
Beyond toasting, you get four functions: toast, bake, broil, and keep warm. The bake function handles small casseroles, frozen pizzas (up to 9 inches), and reheating leftovers without making them soggy. Broiling gets hot enough to melt cheese and crisp the tops of dishes, though I’d recommend keeping the door slightly ajar for better browning. The 30-minute timer with automatic shut-off provides a basic safety net, though it does limit longer slow-cooking tasks.
What buyers consistently praise
The word “even” appears repeatedly in customer feedback. Beyond the toasting performance, users appreciate the compact design — it fits under most kitchen cabinets with room to spare. Multiple reviews mention this is “perfect for a small kitchen” or “great for a dorm room or office.” The simple dial controls also earn consistent praise from older users who find digital touchscreens fiddly. As one reviewer put it, “I don’t need WiFi in my toaster. I need it to make toast. This does that.”
Where it falls short
The lack of an interior light is the biggest annoyance. You’ll have to crack the door open to check browning progress, which lets heat escape and can extend cooking times. The crumb tray is also thinner than I’d like — let it cool completely before cleaning, or you risk warping it. And while the 450°F max temperature is fine for most tasks, it’s not enough for properly roasting vegetables or baking artisan bread. One buyer noted the exterior gets “noticeably warm to the touch” during longer baking sessions, so keep it away from flammable materials.
Who should buy this
This toaster oven is ideal for singles, couples, or small families who want reliable toast and basic baking without spending $150+ on a convection model. It’s also a strong choice for dorm rooms, small apartments, offices, or anyone with limited counter space. If you’re replacing a dedicated toaster and want an oven that can handle frozen pizza, reheating leftovers, and broiling fish, this fits the bill. Skip it if you need convection baking, air frying, or precise temperature control for serious baking projects.
FAQ
Q: Does the Even Toast feature actually make a difference? A: Yes. The heating elements are positioned to distribute heat more evenly across all four slots. Buyers consistently report uniform browning across all slices, which is genuinely rare at this price point.
Q: Can I fit a full-size frozen pizza inside? A: No. The interior accommodates pizzas up to about 9 inches in diameter. Larger pies need to be cut or baked elsewhere.
Q: How loud is the timer when it goes off? A: The bell-style timer is audible but not obnoxious. You’ll hear it from another room, but it won’t startle you or wake a sleeping baby.
The Verdict
Buy it if: You want consistent toast every morning, need a compact countertop oven for basic baking and broiling, or want a reliable budget appliance that doesn’t take up half your counter.
Skip it if: You require convection cooking, a window light, or precise temperature control for serious baking.
The BLACK+DECKER TO1745SSG earns a 4.6/5 rating. It’s not flashy, but it does the one thing a toaster oven absolutely must do — toast evenly — and does it better than many pricier competitors. At this price point, that’s a win.
Price check: As of this review, the TO1745SSG typically retails between $45–$60, making it one of the best value 4-slice toaster ovens available.
Where to Buy
We earn a small commission at no extra cost to you — this helps fund more honest reviews.
Last updated: 2026-08-06. Ratings and prices current as of review date. Verify on Amazon before purchasing.