241798231 241798224 241798211 Ice Maker Replacement, Compati
✅ PROS
- Direct drop-in replacement for Frigidaire/Electrolux/Kenmore models with the 241798231, 241798224, and 241798211 part numbers — no wiring harness splicing required
- Ice mold uses a metal sensing arm and consistent cycle timing that matches OEM output (about 3-4 pounds per 24 hours)
- Includes the full auger motor assembly, so you're not reusing worn gears from your old unit
❌ CONS
- Packaging is minimal — no mounting screws or foam padding included, so check your old unit before tossing it
- Some units arrive with the ice level arm slightly bent in shipping; it's fixable with pliers but annoying
The Verdict
Let’s cut through the noise: when your refrigerator’s ice maker dies, you have two options. Pay a technician $200+ for a service call plus parts, or DIY it with a replacement like this one. At roughly a third of the cost of an OEM part, this aftermarket unit is the kind of purchase that makes you feel like a genius — or a fool if it doesn’t fit.
I’ve combed through the 225 ratings and 4.5-star average, and here’s what actually matters.
What You’re Getting
This is the complete ice maker assembly — not a repair kit. The box contains the full unit: ice mold, water fill cup, ejector blades, the auger motor that rotates the ice bucket, and the electrical harness that plugs directly into your fridge’s wiring. No soldering, no crimping, no praying.
The compatibility list is specific: Frigidaire, Electrolux, and Kenmore refrigerators that use one of the three part numbers in the title (241798231, 241798224, 241798211). Before you order, check the part number on your existing ice maker — it’s printed on a white sticker on the side. If it matches any of those three, you’re in business.
Real-World Performance
The installation is straightforward for anyone who’s replaced a light fixture. Unplug the fridge, remove the old unit (usually two screws and a quarter-turn of the harness connector), slide this one in, and plug it back up. Most buyers report first ice within 24 hours — the standard cycle time.
The ice quality is where this unit surprises. The mold fills completely and ejects cleanly — no half-moons or stuck cubes. One buyer noted, “Dropped right in, made ice in about 6 hours. The cubes are clear and full-sized, just like the original.” The auger motor is quiet, too, though you’ll hear the standard click-clack of the ejector cycle. That’s normal.
What Buyers Consistently Praise
The overwhelming theme in the reviews is it just works. People who’ve been living without ice for weeks are thrilled to have it back. A verified purchase said, “I was quoted $350 by a repair guy. This was $60 and took me 15 minutes. Best money I’ve spent on this fridge.”
Another recurring compliment: the fit is exact. The mounting holes line up, the harness connector matches, and the overall dimensions mirror the OEM part. No shimming, no modifications, no returning it because it’s “close but not quite.”
Where It Falls Short
Let’s be honest about the tradeoffs. The most common complaint is the ice level arm — the metal wire that tells the maker when the bin is full. Several buyers reported it arriving bent or slightly out of alignment. It’s a five-minute fix with a pair of pliers, but it’s the kind of thing that makes you question quality control.
The second issue is packaging. This ships in a plain box with minimal protection. It’s not a fragile part, but the arm issue above suggests it’s getting knocked around in transit.
And one thing to know: this is a generic replacement, not genuine Frigidaire. The plastic molding is slightly different in texture — a bit glossier — and the internal components aren’t branded. If you’re a stickler for OEM parts, this isn’t for you. But functionally, it’s identical.
Who Should Buy This
The DIY homeowner — if you’re comfortable with a screwdriver and basic electrical connections, this is a 30-minute job that saves you a service call.
The budget-conscious repairer — at this price point, you could buy two of these and still come out ahead of a single OEM part or technician visit.
Skip it if you have a fridge that’s not on the compatibility list, or if you’re not comfortable working with electrical connections. There’s no adapter for different wiring.
FAQ
Q: Will this fit my Frigidaire Gallery model? A: Check the part number on your current ice maker. If it’s 241798231, 241798224, or 241798211, yes. If you can’t find the sticker, search your fridge model number online to verify compatibility.
Q: How long does it take to start making ice? A: Most buyers see the first batch within 6-24 hours. The unit needs time to cool down and fill the mold. If nothing happens after 48 hours, check the water line and the harness connection.
Q: Is this a genuine Frigidaire part? A: No, it’s an aftermarket replacement. It’s designed to match OEM specifications, but it’s not branded. The warranty is through the seller, not Frigidaire.
The Verdict
Buy it if: You’re tired of manually filling ice trays and you’ve confirmed the part number matches. This is a solid, functional replacement that does exactly what it claims.
Skip it if: You want OEM parts, or your fridge isn’t on the compatibility list. Also skip if you’re not comfortable with basic electrical work — call a pro instead.
Rating: 4.6/5 — It’s not glamorous, but it’s honest, functional, and saves you real money. The bent-arm issue is annoying but fixable, and the price makes the value proposition undeniable.
Where to Buy
We earn a small commission at no extra cost to you — this helps fund more honest reviews.
Last updated: 2026-08-06. Ratings and prices current as of review date. Verify on Amazon before purchasing.