63XL Black High-Yield Ink Cartridge for HP 63 Black Ink Cart
✅ PROS
- Roughly double the page yield of standard HP 63 cartridges — rated for ~480 pages versus ~190 inch
- Crisp, dark black output with no smudging or banding on plain copy paper in user tests
- Simple tool-free installation; chip registers correctly in most HP Deskjet and Envy models
❌ CONS
- Not a genuine HP product — some users report the printer's ink level indicator showing incorrect remaining amounts
- Ink can dry out faster than OEM if the printer sits unused for several weeks between jobs
The Verdict
Is this third-party 63XL cartridge a smart money-saver or a compatibility gamble?
If you own an HP Deskjet or Envy printer, you already know the sting of replacing ink. The standard HP 63 cartridge barely gets you through a semester of homework or a quarter of home office printing. This 63XL Black High-Yield cartridge promises nearly double the pages for a fraction of OEM cost. After digging through 210 ratings and user experiences, here’s the real picture.
What’s in the box
You get a single black 63XL cartridge, sealed in foil. Nothing else — no instructions needed, no tools. It’s a drop-in replacement for the HP 63 and 63XL cartridges used in Deskjet 1110, 2130, 3630, 3755, Envy 4520, 5530, and similar models. The cartridge body is matte black plastic with a standard chip on the side. If your printer takes two cartridges (black plus tri-color), this replaces only the black one.
Performance and print quality
The headline number here is page yield. This cartridge is rated for approximately 480 pages at 5% coverage — that’s roughly 2.5 times the standard HP 63’s 190-page rating. For a home office printing contracts or a student churning out essays, that’s meaningful. Users consistently report getting “at least 400 pages” before the low-ink warning appears, which tracks with the rating.
Print quality is where this cartridge surprises. Multiple reviewers describe output as “sharp” and “comparable to HP original.” Text comes out dense black with no streaking, and it handles basic graphics without banding. It’s not photo-grade, but for documents, it’s solid. Drying time on plain paper is quick — no smudging when you grab a page right off the output tray.
What buyers praise
The value proposition is the consistent theme. One buyer put it plainly: “Half the price of the HP brand and prints just as good. I’ve bought three of these now.” Another noted, “Works perfectly in my Envy 4520. No error messages, no hassle.” Installation is genuinely tool-free — you pop out the old cartridge, snap this one in, and the printer recognizes it immediately in most cases.
Where it falls short
Let’s be honest about the compromises. This is not a genuine HP cartridge, and that shows in two ways. First, the ink level indicator can be inaccurate. Several users report the printer showing “low ink” while the cartridge still has plenty of life, or occasionally showing full when it’s near empty. You’ll want to keep a spare on hand rather than trusting the meter blindly.
Second, third-party ink tends to dry out faster than OEM if the printer sits idle. If you print weekly, no issue. If you go a month between print jobs, you may waste ink on cleaning cycles or find the cartridge clogged. One reviewer noted, “After three weeks of no printing, I had to run two cleaning cycles before it printed clean.”
Who should buy this
This cartridge makes sense for high-volume home users — families with school-aged kids, remote workers printing daily, or anyone who burns through a standard cartridge every few weeks. If you’re a light user printing once a month, the drying issue makes OEM a safer bet despite the higher cost. It’s also a good choice for budget-conscious students who need reliable output without the retail markup.
FAQ
Will this work with my HP Deskjet 3755?
Yes. The 3755 uses the HP 63 series, and this cartridge is compatible. Just confirm your specific model accepts the 63XL format — most Deskjet and Envy printers from 2016 onward do.
How do I know when it’s actually empty if the indicator is unreliable?
Watch print quality. When text starts looking faint or streaky, the cartridge is genuinely low. The printer’s warning may trigger early, but you can often get another 30–50 pages before it truly runs dry.
Does using a third-party cartridge void my printer warranty?
In the US, the Magnuson-Moss Warranty Act prohibits a manufacturer from voiding a warranty solely because you used a non-OEM consumable. HP can’t legally deny coverage unless they prove the cartridge caused the damage — which is rare.
The Verdict
Buy it if you print regularly and want roughly 2.5x the pages of a standard HP 63 at a lower per-page cost. It’s a practical, reliable choice for everyday document printing.
Skip it if you’re an infrequent printer who might let ink sit for weeks, or if you need absolutely accurate ink level reporting. In those cases, the premium for genuine HP is worth it.
Rating: 4.2/5 — A solid value with minor quirks that don’t outweigh the savings for most users.
Where to Buy
We earn a small commission at no extra cost to you — this helps fund more honest reviews.
Last updated: 2026-08-06. Ratings and prices current as of review date. Verify on Amazon before purchasing.