CRAFTSMAN Screwdriver Set, 12 Pc, Includes Flat Head and Phi
✅ PROS
- Magnetic tips actually hold screws firmly during installation
- Cushioned grips reduce hand fatigue on long jobs
- Heat-treated steel shafts resist bending under heavy torque
❌ CONS
- No case included — drivers will roll around in a toolbox drawer
- Handle diameter is thick for users with smaller hands
- Lacks stubby or precision drivers for tight-space work
The Verdict
You know that moment when you start a project with a $5 screwdriver from the grocery store, and the tip rounds off on the second screw? This CRAFTSMAN 12-piece set is the answer to that frustration. With a 4.8-star average across 240 ratings, it’s clearly earning its place in toolboxes — but it’s not without a few compromises worth knowing before you buy.
What’s actually in the box
This is a straightforward 12-piece set: six Phillips (#0, #1, #2, #3, plus two sizes you’ll actually use daily) and six flat head drivers in common widths. As shown in the product image, each driver features a cushioned grip with a textured surface that gives you solid purchase even with greasy hands. The shafts are made from heat-treated steel, and the tips are precision-ground. CRAFTSMAN backs these with their full lifetime warranty, so if a tip ever snaps, they replace it — no receipt questions asked.
Real-world performance
I put the #2 Phillips through its paces on a deck rebuild, and the magnetic tip is legit. Screws stayed put on the driver even when I was reaching overhead or working at awkward angles — that’s a genuine time-saver. The grip transfers torque well, and the handle design gives you enough surface area to lean into stubborn screws without your palm bruising.
The flat heads bite properly too. The tips are ground square, not tapered like cheap sets, which means they seat fully in the screw slot and don’t cam out. For anyone who’s stripped a screw head with a worn driver, this precision matters.
What buyers consistently praise
The durability keeps coming up in reviews. One verified buyer noted, “I’ve used these daily for six months in my HVAC business — they still look new.” Another mentioned, “The magnetic tips are strong enough to hold a screw upside down, which I didn’t expect at this price.” The lifetime warranty gets frequent shout-outs as well, with users appreciating that CRAFTSMAN honors it without hassle.
Where it falls short
The biggest miss: there’s no storage case. These drivers will rattle around loose in your toolbox, and you’ll likely have to hunt for the size you need. For roughly the same money, some competitors include a molded organizer.
The handle diameter is also on the thicker side. If you have smaller hands, you’ll find these less comfortable for extended precision work. And there’s no stubby or precision driver in this set — you’ll need a separate purchase for tight spaces or electronics work.
Who should buy this
This set is ideal for the weekend DIYer who’s tired of replacing cheap screwdrivers every few months. It’s also a smart pick for new homeowners building their first basic toolkit. HVAC techs and electricians who need reliable daily drivers will appreciate the durability and warranty. Skip it if you do fine electronics repair (you need precision drivers) or if you’re a professional who needs a full range of sizes with a storage solution.
FAQ
Is the lifetime warranty really hassle-free? Yes. CRAFTSMAN’s warranty covers breakage or defects. You contact their support, and they ship a replacement. No receipt required for most claims.
Are the handles comfortable for heavy use? Generally yes, but the thicker diameter is a consideration. Users with larger hands report excellent comfort; those with smaller hands find them slightly bulky.
Can these handle impact use with a hammer? No — these are standard screwdrivers, not impact-rated. Use a proper impact driver for that kind of work.
The Verdict
Buy it if you want a reliable, durable screwdriver set that will outlast the cheap alternatives and come with a real warranty. Skip it if you need a storage case, precision sizes, or have smaller hands that struggle with thick grips.
Rating: 4.6/5 — Solid performers that get the essentials right, minus the case and size variety.
Where to Buy
We earn a small commission at no extra cost to you — this helps fund more honest reviews.
Last updated: 2026-08-06. Ratings and prices current as of review date. Verify on Amazon before purchasing.