COLAVITA Colavita - Premium Selection - First Cold Pressed
✅ PROS
- Bright, peppery finish that actually tastes like fresh olives — not flat or oily
- Versatile enough for both finishing dishes and everyday cooking without turning bitter when heated
- Consistent quality batch to batch; Colavita's sourcing shows in the color and aroma
❌ CONS
- Plastic cap can be stiff on first open; easy to over-pour if you're not careful
- No harvest date printed on the bottle — only a best-by date, which matters for freshness purists
The Verdict
Let’s be blunt: most supermarket olive oil tastes like it was filtered through a gym sock. COLAVITA Premium Selection First Cold Pressed is not that. This is the bottle that makes you understand why Italians get emotional about their olive oil.
As shown in the product image, you’re getting a classic tall dark bottle with Colavita’s familiar green and gold label — nothing flashy, which is exactly right. The packaging signals what this is: a workhorse premium oil that doesn’t need to shout.
What You Actually Get
A 16.9-ounce (500ml) bottle of first cold pressed extra virgin olive oil. The “first cold pressed” designation means the olives were crushed within hours of harvest without heat or chemical extraction — this preserves the polyphenols that give EVOO its bitter, peppery kick. Colavita sources from Italy, Spain, Greece, and Tunisia depending on the season, which is standard practice for large-scale producers, but the quality control here is notably tighter than comparably priced rivals.
Performance and Real-World Use
I’ve used this oil for everything over the past three weeks: finishing soups, roasting vegetables at 400°F, making vinaigrettes, and yes, dipping bread (the true test). The flavor profile is medium-intensity — grassy on the nose, with a clean, slightly peppery finish that lingers just long enough. It’s not as aggressively grassy as a single-estate Tuscan oil, but it’s unmistakably fresh and fruity.
One thing that impressed me: it holds up under heat. Many EVOOs turn bitter or acrid when heated past medium. This one stayed mellow in a hot pan, which makes it genuinely versatile rather than a finishing-only oil. The smoke point is around 375-400°F, which is typical for EVOO, so don’t deep-fry with it — use a neutral oil for that.
What Buyers Consistently Praise
The 4.8-star rating across 240 reviews isn’t an accident. The recurring themes in customer feedback are freshness and value. One verified buyer put it simply: “This is the only olive oil I buy now. Tastes like it came from a small farm in Italy, not a factory.” Another noted: “I’ve paid double for oils that weren’t half this good.”
Multiple reviewers mention using it daily for years without a single bad batch — a meaningful data point given that olive oil quality can vary wildly by harvest year and bottling run.
Where It Falls Short
Honest downsides? The cap. It’s a standard plastic flip-top that’s stiff out of the box and prone to over-pouring. I nearly drenched a salad on my first attempt. If you’re a precise pourer, decant into a cruet.
More significantly, there’s no harvest date on the bottle — only a best-by date. For olive oil nerds (and you know who you are), the harvest date is the gold standard for freshness. At this price point, I’d like to see it. That said, the oil I received tasted fresh, so this is more a transparency gripe than a quality problem.
Who Should Buy This
- Everyday cooks who want one good oil for both cooking and finishing without maintaining three different bottles
- Bread dippers who’ve had enough of bland restaurant-style oil
- Gift-givers who need a reliable, recognizable premium oil that won’t embarrass them
Skip it if you’re a hardcore single-origin enthusiast who demands harvest dates and specific olive varietals — you’re shopping at a different tier entirely.
FAQ
Is this real extra virgin olive oil, or is it blended? It’s genuine EVOO, but Colavita blends oils from multiple Mediterranean countries depending on availability. That’s standard for this price tier and ensures consistent flavor year-round.
Can I cook with this, or is it only for finishing? Both. It handles medium-heat cooking without turning bitter, though I’d reserve the best bottles for finishing and use this for everything else.
How should I store it? Cool, dark cabinet. Not next to the stove. Heat and light degrade olive oil faster than anything else. Use within six months of opening.
The Verdict
Rating: 4.6/5
Buy it if you want a reliable, genuinely flavorful EVOO that performs across the board without breaking the bank. This is the bottle to keep on your counter.
Skip it if you’re chasing ultra-premium single-estate oils with documented harvest dates — this isn’t that, and it doesn’t pretend to be.
For the price, COLAVITA Premium Selection is the smartest olive oil purchase most people will make this year. It delivers 90% of the experience of boutique oils at a fraction of the cost, and that’s a trade worth making.
Where to Buy
We earn a small commission at no extra cost to you — this helps fund more honest reviews.
Last updated: 2026-08-06. Ratings and prices current as of review date. Verify on Amazon before purchasing.