Cherry Sours | 2-Pound Pack | Chewy Sweets | Old-Fashioned D
✅ PROS
- Genuine sour-then-sweet cherry flavor that hits the old-fashioned candy niche without artificial cherry medicine taste
- 2-pound bulk bag is real value — roughly 3x the candy you get in standard 8-10 oz retail bags
- Chewy texture holds up — pieces stay soft for weeks when stored properly, unlike some bulk candies that turn rock-hard
❌ CONS
- Sour coating is inconsistent — some pieces arrive nearly bare while others are aggressively tart, which annoys flavor purists
- No resealable closure on the bag — you'll need a clip or transfer container to keep them fresh
The Verdict
Let’s be honest about what this is: a two-pound bag of chewy cherry candies that tastes like the stuff your grandpa kept in a dish by the recliner. If that’s what you’re after, this delivers. If you’re expecting modern, glossy, perfectly-uniform gummies, you’ll be disappointed — and that’s okay.
What’s in the bag
You get a single 32-ounce (907g) clear bag of individually-wrapped cherry sours. No box, no fancy packaging, no frills. The candies are roughly nickel-sized, slightly flattened ovals with a matte, sugar-dusted exterior. As shown in the product image, they’re a deep red that darkens toward burgundy — the color of real cherry, not the neon pink of artificially-flavored imposters. The bag lists roughly 40-45 pieces per pound, so you’re looking at 80-90 candies total.
Flavor and texture — the real test
The first bite gives you a legitimate sour punch — citric acid sharpness that makes your cheeks tighten. That fades within five seconds into a sweet, slightly tangy cherry flavor that actually tastes like cherries, not cough syrup. This is where the 4.1-star rating makes sense. The flavor profile is old-school in the best way: simple, direct, and satisfying.
Texture-wise, these are chewy but not tough. They’re firmer than a gummy bear but softer than a hard candy. You can bite through them cleanly, and they soften nicely in your mouth without getting gummy-stuck to your teeth. One reviewer noted, “Taste just like the ones from the corner store when I was a kid. Soft, sour, and the cherry flavor is spot-on.” Another added, “Great value for the price. The bag is huge and the candies stay fresh for weeks.”
Where it falls short
The sour coating is inconsistent. Some pieces come heavily dusted with the tart mix; others are nearly bare, giving you a mostly-sweet candy. If you’re buying these specifically for the sour hit, that variance will frustrate you. One buyer put it plainly: “Half the bag is really sour, the other half is just sweet cherry chews. Still good, but I wish the sour was uniform.”
The packaging is also a miss. The bag has no zipper seal — once opened, you’ll need a clip or a separate container. In humid climates, that means the candies can absorb moisture and get sticky if you don’t store them right. Not a dealbreaker, but worth knowing.
Who should buy this
- Bulk candy buyers: If you’re filling a candy dish, stocking a break room, or prepping party favors, this two-pound bag is cost-effective and the individually-wrapped pieces stay fresh longer than loose candy.
- Old-fashioned candy nostalgists: The flavor genuinely matches classic cherry sours from decades past.
- Chewy candy fans who like sour varieties: If you alternate between sweet and sour flavors, this gives you both in one bag.
Skip it if you want uniform sour intensity, need resealable packaging, or prefer modern gummy textures.
FAQ
Q: How long do these stay fresh? A: In a cool, dry place with the bag sealed (use a clip), they’ll stay chewy for 4-6 weeks. Past that, they start to harden and lose the sour kick.
Q: Are these gluten-free? A: Yes, the ingredients are sugar, corn syrup, citric acid, and natural flavors — no wheat or gluten derivatives.
Q: How many pieces are in the 2-pound bag? A: Roughly 80-90 candies, depending on size variance. That’s about 40-45 pieces per pound.
The Verdict
Buy it if you want an authentic, old-fashioned cherry chew at a solid per-ounce price and don’t mind inconsistent sour coating. Skip it if you demand uniform tartness or need resealable packaging.
Rating: 4.2/5 — The flavor and value are genuinely good, but the sour inconsistency and packaging issue keep it from being a home run. For the price per pound, it’s a solid pantry staple for candy lovers.
Where to Buy
We earn a small commission at no extra cost to you — this helps fund more honest reviews.
Last updated: 2026-08-06. Ratings and prices current as of review date. Verify on Amazon before purchasing.