📬 Never miss a verdict — subscribe to our newsletter and get the latest reviews delivered to your inbox.

Mr Pen Combination Square Combo vs THORVALD Carpenter Square: Which Is the Smarter Buy?

| By The Shopper's Verdict

Two Squares, One Winner: Mr Pen vs THORVALD

You need a square that’s actually square. The Mr Pen Combination Square Combo and the THORVALD 6-in-1 Carpenter Square both claim to deliver accurate 90° and 45° angles without the premium price tag. But they take very different routes to get there — and one is the smarter buy for most people.

We’ve dug through thousands of real Amazon reviews, our own hands-on notes, and the spec sheets to settle it. Both score a strong 4.6/5 in our verdict, but they’re built for different buyers. Here’s the head-to-head.

Quick Summary

Best overall: Mr Pen Combination Square Combo — verdict 4.6/5. It costs about a third of the THORVALD, includes a level and scriber, and covers the everyday layout tasks most DIYers and woodworkers actually face. If you want one square that does 90% of the jobs without overspending, this is it.

Check Price on Amazon

Best for precision and versatility: THORVALD 6-in-1 Carpenter Square — verdict 4.6/5. At roughly $23, it costs more than double, but its 6-in-1 design and 1/16" precision markings make it the pick for finish carpenters, trim work, and anyone who needs repeatable accuracy. If precision is non-negotiable, spend the extra.

That’s the short version. The long version — specs, where each wins, where each falls short — is below.

Key Specs Side by Side

| Feature | Mr Pen Combination Square Combo | THORVALD 6-in-1 Carpenter Square | |—

|---|---| | **Price** | ~$10.30 | ~$23.05 | | **Our verdict** | 4.6/5 | 4.6/5 | | **Amazon rating** | 4.6/5 | 4.7/5 | | **Number of reviews** | 2,045 | 1,946 | | **Core design** | Combination square (12" blade) with level and scriber | 6-in-1 carpenter square with 7" blade, 1/16" precision markings | | **Best for** | DIY, general carpentry, home improvement | Finish carpentry, trim, precision layout | | **Included extras** | Level, scriber, cast zinc body | Multi-function head, precision etched markings | | **Buy** | Check Price on Amazon | View Amazon Deals |

Both tools earn the same verdict score from us, but the price gap is real: the Mr Pen is less than half the cost of the THORVALD. So the question isn’t which is “better” in a vacuum — it’s which is better for the work you actually do.

Where the Mr Pen Combination Square Combo Wins

1. Price-to-performance is outstanding

At around $10, the Mr Pen is one of the cheapest ways to get a functional combination square with a level and scriber included. For most DIYers, that’s all the square they’ll ever need. You could buy two and still spend less than one THORVALD.

2. It covers the everyday jobs

A combination square is the Swiss Army knife of layout tools: 90° and 45° checks, depth marking, level checks, and scribing. The Mr Pen does all of that out of the box. If you’re hanging shelves, building a workbench, or checking cabinet corners, it’s plenty.

3. The included level and scriber save you a trip

Many budget squares make you buy a scriber separately. Mr Pen bundles it, along with a vial level in the head. That’s genuinely useful for quick leveling tasks where hauling out a spirit level is overkill.

4. Huge review base

With over 2,000 Amazon ratings and a 4.6 average, the Mr Pen has a deep track record. That’s not a guarantee, but it’s a strong signal that most buyers get a square, accurate tool.

Our full review: Mr Pen Combination Square Combo review

Check Availability

Where the THORVALD 6-in-1 Carpenter Square Wins

1. Precision is the headline

The THORVALD is built around 1/16" precision markings on a 7" blade. For trim carpenters and finish work, that matters. If you’re cutting miters for crown molding or laying out cabinet hardware, a square that’s slightly off will show in the finished product. The THORVALD’s etched markings are designed to stay legible and accurate.

2. Six functions in one tool

“6-in-1” isn’t just marketing — it means the head doubles as a try square, miter square, protractor, and more. That versatility is why finish pros like it: fewer tools in the pouch, faster layout.

3. Slightly higher Amazon rating

A 4.7/5 average across nearly 2,000 reviews is excellent. Buyers consistently praise its accuracy and build quality, which is what you’d hope for at this price.

4. Better for repeatable, precise work

If your work demands consistent 1/16" accuracy, the THORVALD is the more confidence-inspiring tool. The Mr Pen is fine for rough framing and DIY, but the THORVALD is the one you reach for when the cut has to be right the first time.

Our full review: THORVALD 6-in-1 Carpenter Square review

See Today’s Price

Where Each Falls Short

Mr Pen Combination Square Combo — the trade-offs

  • Precision is good, not exceptional. For finish carpentry, the markings aren’t as refined as the THORVALD’s. Most DIYers won’t notice, but pros will.
  • Build feels budget. At this price, the cast zinc head and blade are functional but not heirloom quality. Treat it well and it’ll last; drop it off a ladder and you may knock it out of square.
  • Not a 6-in-1. You get the core combination-square functions, but not the extra protractor/try-square versatility of the THORVALD.

THORVALD 6-in-1 Carpenter Square — the trade-offs

  • Price. At ~$23, it’s more than double the Mr Pen. For occasional DIY use, that’s hard to justify.
  • Overkill for simple jobs. If you just need to check a corner is 90°, the extra functions and precision are wasted.
  • Smaller blade. The 7" blade is shorter than the Mr Pen’s 12" blade, which can matter for larger layout work.

Neither tool is perfect, but their weaknesses are aimed at different buyers. The Mr Pen’s weakness (refinement) only matters to pros. The THORVALD’s weakness (price) only matters to casual users.

Who Each Square Is For

Choose the Mr Pen Combination Square Combo if:

  • You’re a DIYer, homeowner, or beginner woodworker.
  • You want one versatile square for framing, shelving, and general layout.
  • You value the included level and scriber.
  • You’d rather spend $10 than $23 and put the savings toward lumber.

Choose the THORVALD 6-in-1 Carpenter Square if:

  • You do finish carpentry, trim work, or furniture building.
  • You need repeatable 1/16" precision.
  • You want multiple functions (try square, miter square, protractor) in one tool.
  • You’re a pro or serious hobbyist who’ll use it weekly.

The Verdict: Which Is the Smarter Buy?

For most people, the Mr Pen Combination Square Combo is the smarter buy. It covers the vast majority of layout tasks at a price that’s easy to justify, and its 4.6/5 verdict score matches the THORVALD’s. If you’re outfitting a home workshop or just need a reliable square for weekend projects, buy the Mr Pen and don’t look back.

But “most people” isn’t everyone. If your work lives or dies on precision — trim, cabinetry, finish work — the THORVALD 6-in-1 Carpenter Square is worth the extra ~$13. Its 1/16" precision and 6-in-1 versatility are real advantages that show up in the finished product. For pros, it’s the smarter buy.

Still torn? Read our full Mr Pen review and THORVALD review for deeper dives.

Final Verdict

Winner for most people: Mr Pen Combination Square Combo (4.6/5). It delivers 90% of the functionality at less than half the price, with a level and scriber included. For DIYers and general carpentry, it’s the clear value pick.

Winner for precision work: THORVALD 6-in-1 Carpenter Square (4.6/5). Spend the extra if accuracy and versatility are non-negotiable.

Check Price on Amazon

We earn from qualifying purchases. Prices and ratings are accurate as of publication and may change.

As an Amazon Associate, we earn from qualifying purchases. Our verdicts are based on real customer reviews, not affiliate commissions.

Browse all verdicts →